All posts by Akberally Meherally

An Open Letter from a former Ismaili Missionary Who came to Islam

I am a revert to Islām. I was a Ismāʿīli before – a follower of the Aga Khan. I perceive an important da’wāh responsibility which the majority of Muslims, for some reason or other, are ignoring. I am not getting you into petty sectarian issues, but a very important matter – please judge for yourself:

1. The Ismāʿīlis (followers of the Aga Khan) all professedly believe that the
Qurʾān was time-bound and was not meant to be a Universal message for all times. They believe that their spiritual leader, Karim Aga Khan, is the “walking and talking Qurʾān” and his religious pronouncements (farmāns) are the guidance for the present times. The fundamental article of faith that there will not be any NEW revelations or “wahy” after the Qurʾān, is being completely violated by the Ismāʿīlis.

2. The Aga Khan has officially Declared himself, before his followers, as the “Mazhar of Allāh on earth”. The word “mazhar” means “copy” or “manifest”. Consequently, these Ismāʿīlis who call themselves Muslims do “sujood” before him. So even the primary axiomatic principle of Tawheed is being fundamentally and formally violated by them.

3. The Ismāʿīlis are not instructed to offer the Islamic Salaah, observe Saum or perform Hajj. They have replaced Salaah with certain shirk-infested Dua’as (thrice a day). They are told that their Hajj is a personal “Glimpse” (Deedaar) of Karim Aga Khan.

4. The Aga Khan and his appointees ‘forgive the sins’ of the followers on regular basis. Ismāʿīlis are misled into believing that they will not be questioned on the Day of Judgment for the sins that are already forgiven in their Jamatkhanas (community centers). Forgiving of sins is the exclusive prerogative and privilege of Allāh alone. Qur’an 3:135.

5. Against this backdrop, most of the poor (spiritually poor) Ismāʿīlis who are not introduced to Qurān are confused and misguided. Hence, Ismāʿīlis are very easy prey to missionary efforts by various Christian groups and Baha’is. I have known a couple of young ex-Ismāʿīlis who are today preaching “Pauline Christianity” to Ismāʿīlis as evangelical missionaries.

6. Karim Aga Khan’s own daughter Zahra marrying a practicing Christian (Mark Boyden) has opened the gates for young Ismāʿīli girls to follow the footsteps of a family member of their beloved Imām-e-Zaman. The parents of the Ismāʿīli girls who wish to marry outside of Islām have no recourse but to let them go.

7. The Aga Khan has made halāl for the Ismāʿīlis that which Allāh has made harām for the humans. Interest (usury) is not forbidden by the religious instruction classes run by the “Tariqah” board of the Ismāʿīlis. As a matter of fact, the much publicized “Venture Capital” program (details on the website of FORBES Magazine – search under “Aga Khan”), of loaning funds on interest by the AKFED (Aga Khan Fund for Economic Development), has been a great success. Similar entrepreneurial projects are now being actively promoted and introduced to poor Muslims of Tajikistan and neighboring areas.

8. The Muslim ummah and the various Muslim leaders are not fully aware of these un-Islamic acts and beliefs of this community of less than two million members, who claim to be the Ismāʿīli Muslims. Surprisingly, their leader Aga Khan claims himself to be a spiritual leader of 15 million Muslims and a direct descendant of Prophet Muhammad (Sallallāhu ‘Alayhi wa Sallam).

9. Earlier, one did not have authentic books on Ismāʿīlism, but it is not so anymore. There are two authentic books as well as this comprehensive website ( exposing the inner practices of the
Ismāʿīlis and the proclamations (farmans) of the Aga Khans. Hence, now you have no “hujjah” argument or excuse left before Allāh for not taking up the task of inviting the misguided “Ismāʿīli Muslims” towards the Deen of Allāh (swt) and not safeguarding them from committing unpardonable sin of Shirk.

10. The Aga Khan in collaboration with so many Western powers and aid funds, has set up the world-wide Aga Khan Development Network (AKDN) which runs several institutions and service companies both in the profit and not-for-profit sectors. This network is very actively operating in Pakistan, India, Tanzania, Uganda, Kenya and Bangladesh, and has now started concentrating its efforts in Tajikistan and the neighboring areas where there is a concentration of Muslims who have not known or openly practiced Islām for the decades. By taking up economical, social, educational and rural development efforts through NGOs (Non-Govt. Organizations) within the AKDN, the Ismāʿīlis and the Aga Khan have gained wide acceptance amongst these countries and masses. Hence this urgent appeal.

11. Now all these beneficiaries are “obliged and grateful” to the Aga Khan and his followers and his organizations for the much-needed schools, medical centers, hospitals, various projects and programmes. In this manner they are penetrating and infiltrating the support system – and one fine day, the Muslim ummah will wake up to the unexpected realization that they have a community of so called Muslims, practicing the Un-Islamic Tariqaah, in charge of all core and support activities. Each of these much-needed projects will have the photos of Aga Khan decorating the walls.

In the name of Allāh (swt) and Islām, kindly urge our Brothers and Sisters to do Da’wah to the Ismāʿīlis, who otherwise will, on the day of judgement, hold us responsible for not conveying the Revealed Truth to them. Dear Brother/Sister, you know much more on the subject than what little I have learnt since reverting to the Deen of Allāh (swt). It hurts to see the misguided simple minded people die on SHIRK because we did not amply warn them before their deaths.

I am aware of your stature as a religious leader of repute, respectability and acceptance among Muslim Masses, and hence have sought to put this appeal to you. I request you to seriously consider this request and initiate all steps that you consider Wajib and appropriate. To spread the “Truth” and eradicate “Tagoot” is a significant, major Sunnah of the prophet (Sallallaahu Alayhi Wasallam).

May I also request you to please forward this post to at least five (if not all) of your Muslim friends and activists so that greater awareness of this issue is created, and this request reaches a wider audience. Please do so. Jazak Allāh Khair.

In case you wish to seek any further clarification please feel free to e-mail me. I will in sha’ Allāh respond. I apologize in advance, if this happens to be a repeat message.

May Allāh shower His choicest blessings on the entire Muslim Ummah. May Almighty Allāh bless you and keep you in the service of Islām and Muslims. Aameen.

Yours in the service of Islām,

Akbarally Meherally

A God Among Us: Do Ismaili Imāms have Aql-e-Kul?

God Among Us - July 2018

In 1946, my father Ebrahim Rajan Meherally had donated 300,000 Indian rupees for the Diamond Jubilee of Aga Khan III. This amount in today’s terms and value, after more than seven decades, would be equivalent to millions of U.S. Dollars. Since that amount was the highest donation from amongst the Ismāʿīlis of India, my father had the exclusive honor of weighing the late Aga Khan in the Diamonds. In the picture here, my father is seen placing the boxes of the diamonds, on the weighing scale.


The weighing in ceremony of the Aga Khan in Diamonds is in progress. My father is placing the boxes containing the Diamonds on the scale. Aga Khan is seen sitting on a sofa of the scale, wearing a big turban. Bombay, March 10th, 1946.

In Ismāʿīli tradition, the belief is that “Hazar Imām is the Mazhar of Allāh and is Aql-e-Qul” ( meaning, the living Imām is the All-Wise and All-Knowing Manifestation of Allāh).  Like all devout Ismāʿīlis, my father too had the firm belief that Aga Khan possessed a divine power and a ‘Noorani vision’ which enabled him to predict future events with certainty. It is common even in the present-day to see Ismāʿīlis flocking to Canada as per Aga Khan’s instructions. If tomorrow Aga Khan were to instruct Ismāʿīlis to leave Canada and go to Australia,  the very next day Ismāʿīlis would start selling their businesses and tender their resignations in a rush to obtain immigration visas for Australia.

My Father’s Move to Congo on Aga Khan’s Instructions

A similar immigration advice was made to my father by Aga Khan III. Since my father was one of the most, if not the most prominent donor in the Ismāʿīli community, he maintained constant correspondence with Aga Khan. My father emigrated from Bombay in the year 1953 and went to East Africa (present-day Kenya). He wrote a letter to Aga Khan seeking his guidance and blessings for the establishment of his business and a quick settlement in Africa. In response, my father was explicitly suggested by Aga Khan to move to Belgian Congo from East Africa. Aga Khan told him that the British Colonies of the East Africa will be the first to get independence, and Belgian Congo will be the last country in Africa to be independent. Therefore, the move to Belgian Congo would provide a longer-term stable business environment.

My father being a devout follower of Aga Khan, immediately moved from East Africa and settled himself in Leopoldville, Belgian Congo (now known as Kinshasha, Zaire), in 1954.

A Visit to Villa Yakimour and Aga Khan’s Inquiry for move to Congo

In December 1954, me and my wife had the opportunity to visit Europe and requested an audience with the Aga Khan. The day soon arrived – it was the early morning of December 9th 1954, when we left our hotel in Nice (France) and went out looking for a taxi with a driver that could converse with us in English. I found one and hired that taxi for the day. We asked the driver to take us to Villa Yakimour in Cannes. The Private Secretary to Aga Khan had suggested that we should take a public bus from Nice to Cannes and then hire a local taxi, to save money. My wife was expecting a child, the weather was very cold. Since none of us spoke French, it was not easy to find our way in the South of France under these conditions and reach in time for our appointment in a different town. In those days, we both were young and very dedicated and devout followers of the Aga Khan. This appointment to meet and talk face to face with our Hazar Imam and his young Begum meant a lot to us. We could not take the risk of being late and miss this once in a lifetime appointment of a private Deedar and Mulaqat.

Yakimour Party Evans Evans, Jogn Frankenheimer, Natalie Wood, Warren Beatty, Yvette, 15th CFF
Party at Villa Yakimour – Evans Evans, John Frankenheimer, Natalie Wood, Warren Beatty and Yvonne Blanche Labrousse (Begum Om Habibeh, at the occasion of 15th Cannes Film Festival.

Our taxi arrived at the Villa in Cannes, earlier than our appointment time. We requested the gatekeeper to inform the Secretary of our presence. We were told to enter the Villa enjoy the beautiful garden, see the private swimming pool of the Aga Khan, take photographs of these sites and wait for the next message. We made the most of this rare photo opportunity.


Finally, the seventy-seven year-old Sultan Muhammad Shah and his fourth wife Yvonne Blanche Labrousse (Begum Om Habibeh), who was nearly forty years younger than him, were ready to meet us. We slowly climbed the steps leading to the residence above. We had to be extra careful in climbing these steps since beautiful flowers were planted between the joints of the rocks with which these steps were made. Yvonne Blanche Labrousse (Begum Om Habibeh), who was pushing the wheel chair of her husband who could not walk, greeted us with her candid smile. The Aga Khan also welcomed our visitation as his devoted followers and asked us to come closer. The Aga Khan was wearing a heavy camel color overcoat and heavy blanket of the same color covered his legs to keep him warm. From time to time, the Begum would pull up the blanket which kept on sliding down due to his body movements.

om habibeh sculptress

We paid homage and offerings to our spiritual leader as any devout Ismāʿīli would on such occasions. He accepted the offerings and showered us with his usual paternal and maternal blessings. Thereafter, my wife made a request for the name of our second child which she was then bearing. My second son Abbas, who was born three months later, has the name that was given on that day.

When all the religious ceremonies were over, the Aga Khan asked me if I had made my plans for going to Belgian Congo. I was caught off-guard and I replied that I had not considered any plans of moving to Africa. I was at that time living in Pakistan and only a few days ago my parents, whom we had met in London, had suggested that I should move to Belgian Congo where my parents had already moved early in the same year.

As devout Ismāʿīlis, my wife and wondered if it was a miracle or his divine power that out of all the things to talk about the Aga Khan spoke of Congo when we had not even given him the slightest hint of our conversation with my parents in London. It was only later that I came to know that the Aga Khan used to maintain personal files of families of all key office-bearers and donors and it was the job of his secretary to make sure that the Aga Khan would review the file of every person he was meeting. Needless to mention, Aga Khan must have reviewed our family file before meeting us that morning.

Leaving Yakimour

When we were about to leave Villa Yakimour, the Begum asked us if we would like to take our photographs with her husband. In the happiest excitement of the special Mulaqat, the child’s name and the out of the blue mention of Congo, we had totally forgotten about the photos. She very generously offered to take the snaps with my Roliflex camera. Thereafter, my wife suggested that I should take the photos of the Aga Khan and his beautiful wife – the former Miss Lyon of 1930. The Begum suggested that she would request her Secretary to take the photos so that we all can come in the picture. Below is that memorable picture taken by the Begum’s secretary.

Photo taken at Villa Yakimour, Cannes, 9 December, 1954
Me and my wife with Aga Khan III and his wife Yvonne Blanche Labrousse – Photo taken at Villa Yakimour, Cannes, 9 December, 1954

It was now time to go down those flowery steps, get into a taxi and head back home. At this moment, the Begum noticed that my wife was wearing her silken Sari but had no overcoat to cover her body from the cold weather. She inquired about the overcoat and was informed that my wife had left it in the taxi below. She immediately whispered into the ear of her husband and he asked me to give my overcoat to my wife. Begum was happy to see my wife wearing my overcoat. She gave her usual smile and they both waved us good-bye, not knowing that we were to meet again, after two days.

From Nice to Rome

On 11th of December 1954 we arrived with our baggage at the airport in Nice. It was a small airport and our twin engine plane which was to fly us to Rome was waiting on the tarmac. Before the passengers would embark on the plane, a big car with the police escort come right up to the tail of the airplane. Out came the Aga Khan and his Begum. The couple was holding diplomatic passports and was the first to embark the plane. Once they had settled comfortably in their seats, the rest of the passengers numbering a dozen or so were allowed to embark. When Aga Khan saw me and my wife entering the airplane he surprisingly shouted: “Mr. Meherally, you did not tell me you were traveling on this plane.” I replied to him that I had no such plans on that day of the Mulaqat.


During the journey, Begum and I exchanged the seats. She sat with my wife and I sat next to the Aga Khan. We briefly discussed about my article on the subject of “The Ismāʿīli Theory of Ten Incarnations – Das Avatar”, which I had already sent to him.

This article was based upon ‘Juni Gatpat ni Dua’ (the old Ismaili prayer that was recited in the 1950s and published in Gujrati from the Ismaili Press in Bombay) and on a Gujrati text book for the religious night schools, entitled; ‘Silsila-e-Imamat’ (the continuous lineage of Imamate). Aga Khan promised to send me his approval and suggested that I should get it printed in the Ismaili magazines.

While Aga Khan and myself were discussing the Ismāʿīli beliefs of the unceasing physical manifestations of God as Avatars and the “Triune of Allah” (Allah, Muhammad and ʿAlī) vis-à-vis the “Trinity of Christian Doctrine” (The Heavenly Father, Jesus Christ and the Holy Ghost), my wife informed the Begum that as the winner of an essay competition, I was awarded a free trip to London and Rome. During the showing of the famous movie Roman Holiday (starring, Audrey Hepburn and Gregory Peck), the film studio in Rome, the owners of the theater in Karachi and the traveling agents had jointly sponsored the free trip to Europe to the winner of an essay ‘The City of Rome’. The panel of judges had declared me the winner and hence I was on this trip with my wife. Begum gave this good news to her husband who turned around, smiled at me and asked; if I was that lucky winner?


Later during the flight some technical difficulties arose and the engine on our side of the airplane came to a complete stop. The propeller was stationary. The airplane was virtually flying on a single engine. The propeller on the side of the Aga Khan was rotating. He and his Begum were unaware of this stoppage of one engine. When the Begum came to us for a chat we informed her of the situation. She looked outside from our window and saw the stationary propeller with an awe. She requested us not to tell of the engine failure to her husband who had by then fallen fast asleep.

Aga Khan was not in good health – the Begum repeated her request. We agreed not to say anything. Throughout the journey, the Begum kept on looking at the stationery propeller to see if it had restarted. Finally, we landed in Rome. The pilot (probably requested by the Begum) made no mention of this abnormality to the passengers, during the flight. At the airport in Rome, the Aga Khan and his Begum were the first to disembark and got into their car which was driven right up to the airplane. The couple waited till we both got down and wished us a happy journey. They kept on waving to us from their car. Begum, who loved her husband so much and used to take great care of her husband, must had been happy that we had observed the silence as requested by her.


Back in Karachi – Reminder of moving to Congo

Shortly after I came back to Karachi, I received the letter of approval of my article “The Ismāʿīli Theory of Ten Incarnations – Das Avatar”. It was an endorsement to the Ismāʿīli  belief in the ten manifestations of Lord Vishnu, with the Prophet’s (pbuh) companion ʿAlī (ra) being the tenth and final physical manifestation of Lord Vishnu.

At the bottom of the letter, the Aga Khan wrote in his own shaky handwriting:

“When do you go to the Congo?” – Aga Khan

My wife and I considered this line of repeated questioning to be an insinuation. I hurriedly submitted my letter to chief missionary Al-Waiz Kassamali Mohammed Jaffer in Karachi who forwarded the article to Bombay from where my my article was published in the Ismaili magazine “Ayina”. In his own Memoirs published in the same year, Aga Khan mentioned briefly about all the messengers of the Old and New Testaments and the Qurʾān and went on to mention Krishna, and Ram as Messengers of Allāh. Today, we know that Krishna and Ram were not historical characters that lived physical lives in India, but were fictional characters of Indian mythology.

Nonetheless, I began preparations to move to Congo and in February 1956, after selling my business and personal assets, I finally moved to Léopoldville in Congo with my family.

Life in Congo

In just over a year after we moved to Congo, Yvonne Blanche Labrousse (Om Habibeh) became a widow. Here in Congo, the independence movement gained momentum. On 4 January 1959, a prohibited political demonstration organised in Léopoldville by a Colgolese political party, which was very vocal against Belgian colonial rule, got out of hand. At once, the colonial capital was in the grip of extensive rioting. It took the authorities several days to restore order and, by the most conservative count, several hundred died. The eruption of violence sent a shock-wave through the Congo and Belgium alike. The movement for independence was in full swing.

I left the Congo and came back to Pakistan. From here, began the series of events which were in total contradiction to what Aga Khan had ‘foretold’ his followers: In June 1960 Belgian Congo and in August 1960 French Congo became independent. In the entire continent of Africa, the Congo was the first region (as opposed to being the last, as Aga Khan had predicted) to become independent. Kenya, which was supposed to get its independence first, as Aga Khan had predicted, was actually the last to become independent on December 12, 1963 – all these events seemed to me as if they happened for a reason – as if to prove, that no one but Allāh alone knows what will happen in the future – no matter how much Ismāʿīlis think that Aga Khan is the possessor of Aql-e-Kul, he actually had absolutely no knowledge of future.

Aga Khan himself, knew this very well. Upon his death, he mentioned in his will that his wife, Yvonne Blanche Labrousse (he mentioned this name and not Om Habibeh) would guide the next Aga Khan (Karim Aga Khan) for a period of the first seven years of Karim Aga Khan assuming the position of the Ismāʿīli Imām.

How can a mortal woman who is not an Imām, guide someone who Ismāʿīlis ask health, wealth and happiness from and assume him to be the bearer of all knowledge?

This further solidified all the doubts I had in the divinity of Aga Khan.

dancing with David Niven at Bal de la Rose in Monaco 1968
Yvonne Blanche Labrousse (also known as Om Habibeh or Mata Salamat), dancing with David Niven at Bal de la Rose in Monaco in 1968 – eleven years after the death of her husband, Aga Khan III.


with Prince Serge Obolensky at Imperial Ball Waldorf Astoria NY 14-01-1957
with Prince Serge Obolensky at Imperial Ball in Waldorf Astoria, New York on January 14, 1957.